Advice and Opinion

Property owners shouldn’t panic over land expropriation says Seeff


It is evident that there is a great concern about land reforms amongst South Africa’s property owners. With this being said, there is a huge amount of noise coming from the media and public disclosure which often sends mixed messages.

President Ramaphosa has provided clarity in various media reports and in a recent parliamentary sitting, stating that there will be no wide-scale land grabs of any kind. He made it clear that there will be no nationalisation and that property rights will be protected; there will be zero tolerance towards illegal land grabs. Ramaphosa went on to reiterate that expropriation will be done in a planned manner in pursuance of economic growth.

The Seeff Group’s CEO, Stuart Manning says that there is no need for consumers to fear that their homes will be taken or that it is pointless to invest in property:

“In fact, far from it. The president has been very clear that SA has learnt from the experiences of other countries (including Zimbabwe), in terms of what has worked and what has not, and will not make the same mistakes”.

The president also gave reassurance that the governing party does not intend to erode property rights but rather to ensure that the property rights of all South Africans are strengthened. Manning says further that:

“It should be noted that ratings agencies and other international commentators including the IMF have all urged clarity on land reform which is seen as a vital step to future prosperity and stability”.

“Following US president, Donald Trump’s tweet regarding land expropriation, the Seeff Group is urging buyers and investors to be wary of the noise, misinterpretation and misinformation. He says this is causing unwarranted and unnecessary fear and concerns among consumers about whether they should be investing in property when in fact, it is an excellent time to buy”, says Manning.

“There has been no indication that expropriation will affect ordinary residential property, far from it”, says Manning. “Ramaphosa is on record as stating that the intention is to unlock the economic potential by looking at unused land, derelict buildings, purely speculative land holdings, or circumstances where occupiers have strong historical rights and title holders do not occupy or use their land, such as labour tenancy, informal settlements and abandoned inner-city buildings”.

While agricultural land is a stated target for expropriation, Manning has welcomed the recent developments, pledges of co-operation and undertakings following high level meetings with various agricultural bodies and stakeholders.

“Additionally, South Africans and foreigners should rest assured that SA’s interested parties are keeping an eye on developments and are setting up high level meetings and making representations as needed, all in the interest of the country, the people and property. This includes the Banking Association of South Africa and its managing director, Cas Coovadia, is on record confirming that the banks continue grating property loans including in the agricultural sector and that the banking sector is also committed to land reform”.

While by no means downplaying the seriousness of the matter, Manning says that South Africans need to be reminded that South Africa is in a much stronger position than what Zimbabwe was.

“We have a strong constitution and Chapter Nine institutions and civil rights organisations. SA is also a party to international treaties which require the protection of property rights and we should take encouragement from all of these factors”.

Manning says further that while the economic and political challenges remain an obstacle for the property market, it is important to remember that there is still plenty of activity. Regardless of the state of the economy and market, there will always be people who need to buy and sell for a range of reasons. Deeds office data shows that thousands of sales transactions are still concluded each month and it is important to filter out the negative noise.

“The important take-out is, that while there are challenges, there are opportunities aplenty. Timing the market is impossible, so it is best to work with what we know. There is very little to indicate that there will be any dramatic upward shift in the economy and property market this year, but for as long as people need a roof over their heads, there will be buyers, and with that, opportunities to sell. We certainly would urge buyers not to waste time waiting for a better time to buy”.